Product logins

Find logins to all Clarivate products below.


chevron_left

Navigating the choppy waters of 2027 health exchange enrollment

Navigating the choppy waters of 2027 health exchange enrollment

After years of steady growth, the health exchange marketplaces established by the Affordable Care Act (ACA) are once again facing uncertainty. While the exchanges have not experienced the long-feared death spiral (in which rising healthcare costs among enrollees are no longer offset by a sufficiently large population of younger, healthier participants), concerns about their stability have resurfaced amid a major decline in enrollment due to the non-renewal of enhanced premium credits. Through 2026 open enrollment, people who bought using those credits mostly left the market.

The 2027 open enrollment period has begun to take shape. While it will include most of the same players across 50 states and Washington D.C, changes are myriad, largely driven by the Trump administration.

Enrollment losses

Markets took their expected dive in 2026, with exchange enrollment dropping after years of surging enrollment due to enhanced subsidies that opened exchanges to higher earners.

New Mexico was among the few to gain patient lives thanks to the state funding its own enhanced subsidies for 2026. That relief may be temporary, however, as the fund the state uses to finance those subsidies could be depleted by 2028.The losses did not end with open enrollment, as many enrollees dropped coverage after billing for their new premiums, which were among the biggest increases in years before accounting for the enhanced subsidies ending. With auto-reenrollments and many people reupping with the same plan, the major premium increases might not have landed until the first premium payment.

July 2026 enrollment figures will offer a clearer picture of the impact of coverage losses among people who initially re-enrolled, though most states are already seeing declines in enrollment. Several states with state-run exchanges are providing subsidies to exchange members to offset the high premiums, including Maryland and New York.

Providers take a hit

People who lose exchange coverage are not necessarily finding alternative sources of health insurance. Most have gone uninsured, and the nation’s for-profit health systems have noticed. Both HCA Healthcare and Universal Health Services cut their profit outlooks for 2026, largely due to the decline in exchange plan member utilization, with almost all shifting to self-pay or uninsured. Nonprofit health systems are more likely to feel the impact of the uninsured, with safety-net providers likely to take the brunt.

Hospital lobbies signed onto the ACA for the promise of a surge in covered patients and reductions in uncompensated care. When the Supreme Court made ACA Medicaid expansion optional, uncompensated care never fully went away, but the increase in patients unable to pay negatively impacts health systems.

An opening for non-ACA coverage

CMS will open catastrophic plans, originally intended for enrollees under 30, to a wider audience. With no limit on the number of non-standard plans an insurer can offer, markets could potentially see a glut of policies with limited coverage.

For 2027, catastrophic plans can include an individual deductible up to $10,000 and the ability write a 10-year policy. Insurers might grow reluctant to offer a 10-year policy due the change in health status that can occur in such a long timeframe.

In moving away from the comprehensive coverage, CMS seeks to allow non-network plans as Qualified Health Plans in exchanges. The plans can be sold in state-run exchanges for 2027 and will debut on federal exchanges for 2028. The plans come without a traditional network, instead paying a lump sum toward services, with the member on the hook for the rest of the costs. Advocates tout the flat rate, lower premium, and ability to see any provider willing to accept that flat rate. While lower premiums might lure enrollees, out-of-pocket costs could come with sticker shock. Prevalence of non-network plans should stay small in 2027, as most state-run exchanges have a pro-ACA lean and would be unlikely to authorize such plans. Look for a bigger push in 2028 when CMS allows them on healthcare.gov. If providers don’t buy in, the day of non-network plans could be short.

Expect markets to adopt these new options gradually, as the added cost-sharing is likely to outweigh any savings on premiums. The practice of “silver loading,” increasing premiums on silver plans to increase the level of premium tax credits that plan buyers can receive, has continued (Bipartisan Policy Center Issue Brief, Aug. 26, 2026). The market is likely to continue its path of eligible enrollees sticking with silver plans and those who aren’t opting for bronze plans, which also have low premiums but much-higher deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums.

Marketplaces exits outnumber entrants

Exchanges are likely to see some plan departures for 2027, though perhaps not on the scale of CVS/Aetna’s 2026 exit, which left more than 1 million people needing to find new coverage or risk becoming uninsured. The extent of insurer departures and resulting disruption will vary by market.About a month before open enrollment was scheduled to begin, UnitedHealthcare withdrew from Georgia’s exchange after the insurer and state officials failed to reach agreement on rates. UnitedHealthcare had requested a 54%rate increase for 2027, which state officials said would be unfair to residents. The insurer subsequently decided to exit the exchange.

Georgians losing UnitedHealthcare coverage will have to wait until open enrollment begins to explore alternative plans. The state is not offering a so-called “window shopping period,” which would allow consumers to review plan options and pricing on the exchange website before enrollment opens.

Cigna will depart the exchanges for 2027, impacting 370,000 enrollees nationally. Molina Healthcare continues to winnow its footprint, dropping from 14 states to six, ending its longstanding practice of having its exchange offerings mirror its Medicaid footprint to connect people who lost Medicaid with similar exchange coverage.

Nonprofit CareSource will leave West Virginia, Ohio, and Indiana. The loss of one carrier in Indiana could feel especially impactful, since Elevance Health dominates its home state and its carrier pool has fallen behind similarly sized states. Texas will also lose a major regional payer in Baylor Scott & White, which covered more than 200,000 exchange lives across the Dallas, San Antonio, and Austin markets, Insira data show.

While market competition has undergone ebb and flow, 2027 does not appear to be a tipping point year. Most major exchange players continue to offer plans, and many plans leaving the market have individual circumstances driving their departures.

Continued financial pressures could lead to more frequent insurer exits. Despite its last-minute withdrawal from Georgia, UnitedHealthcare remains a carrier to watch as it made major exchange withdrawals in the past, and it has continued to grow its exchange business as its for-profit competitors CVS/Aetna and Cigna departed. Centene continued to invest in the exchange market even as other insurers exited., and its broad presence across dozens of states should also be monitored.

Payers are expanding into new counties

While some payers are exiting markets, several large insurers in the exchange market are expanding into new counties for 2027 – seeing their competitors’ downsizing as a viable growth opportunity where members need to find coverage. Centene, the largest exchange insurer in the nation, is expanding into 55 additional counties in Alabama, Iowa, Illinois, Louisiana, Michigan, New Jersey and Texas. However, Centene has withdrawn from Delaware (under Ambetter Health) and New Hampshire for next year, which means its geographic footprint won’t change substantially. Oscar Health, one of the fastest-growing exchange payers, has added 140 new counties and is entering South Carolina for the first time in 2027. Once a digitally-focused, New York-based payer, Oscar has grown its assets nationwide and continues an aggressive growth strategy despite the roadblocks and withdrawals from markets, particularly in the commercial line of business.

Other expansion includes Elevance entering 24 counties now offering individual offerings in 18 states in 2027. In addition, Antidote Health, Aspirus Health Plan, Peak Health CalOptima Health and Colorado Access are entering ACA markets.

Further restrictions

New rules continue to emerge from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act passed in July 2025. A proposed rule from the IRS issue in October would prohibit subsidies for plans purchased in a special enrollment period due to income changes, which would exclude anyone who lost Medicaid coverage from noncompliance with work requirements, also beginning in 2027. The rule restricts tax credits to premium tax credits for citizens, noncitizen U.S. nationals and some lawful permanent residents. Lawful immigrants who lose Medicaid coverage due to immigration status would be ineligible.

A separate CMS rule, aimed at suspending licensing of new exchange brokers on HealthCare.gov for 2027, has already drawn a lawsuit from the National Association of Benefits and Insurance Professionals. Fewer brokers could mean fewer outlets for people buying plans, although many still buy exchange plans without broker aid.

Purchasing an exchange plan in case of a major health issue might not be enough, as CMS has begun cutting enrollees who have not used benefits in a calendar year in late 2026, bundling all such cases under elimination of waste and fraud. CMS has targeted 760,000 enrollees, claiming those cases will save the federal government $2.2 billion. While there is fraud in any system, the high number the administration claims as fraud lends doubt to whether all those cases are truly fraudulent.

If all those people are disenrolled, it will represent a small percentage of overall exchange enrollment. However, when combined with the end of enhanced exchange subsidies, the continued effort to chip away at coverage could slowly push those markets toward a cliff of adverse selection.

Learn more about how DRG Fingertip market access insights and lives data can help you navigate the fast-changing U.S. market access landscape here: DRG Fingertip: Market Access Insights and Lives Data | Clarivate

This post was written by Bill Melville, Lead Healthcare Analyst for Insira, and Valerie E. Pillo, Senior Healthcare Analyst at Insira.

Related insights

The latest news, technologies, and resources from our team.

Why ease of administration in new drugs sometimes draws a yawn from payers Why ease of administration in new drugs sometimes draws a yawn from payers
Blog February 26, 2026
Why ease of administration in new drugs sometimes draws a yawn from payers
Relacorilant:  when evidence meets the established evidence bar Relacorilant:  when evidence meets the established evidence bar
Blog February 24, 2026
Relacorilant: when evidence meets the established evidence bar
Key market access considerations for long-acting and alternative delivery therapies Key market access considerations for long-acting and alternative delivery therapies
Blog February 20, 2026
Key market access considerations for long-acting and alternative delivery therapies
chevron_left
chevron_right